College Hill Homes for Sale

Welcome to College Hill, a charming and vibrant subdivision nestled in the heart of Maplewood Township, Essex County, New Jersey. Known for its picturesque tree-lined streets and a strong sense of community, College Hill offers an idyllic setting for families, young professionals, and retirees alike. With its close proximity to New York City, residents enjoy the perfect blend of suburban tranquility and urban convenience.

The homes for sale in College Hill are as diverse as its residents, featuring a delightful mix of architectural styles ranging from classic colonial to modern designs. Many of these homes boast spacious yards, perfect for outdoor gatherings, gardening, or simply enjoying the serene surroundings. Inside, you’ll find well-appointed interiors with updated kitchens, cozy living spaces, and plenty of natural light that creates a warm and inviting atmosphere.

Living in College Hill means embracing a lifestyle filled with amenities. The neighborhood is home to several parks, recreational facilities, and top-rated schools, making it an ideal place for families. Additionally, the vibrant downtown area of Maplewood is just a stone's throw away, offering an array of shops, restaurants, and cultural experiences to explore.

If you’re looking for a place that combines community spirit with modern living, look no further than College Hill. With homes for sale that cater to a variety of tastes and budgets, now is the perfect time to discover the charm and appeal of this wonderful neighborhood. Come and see why College Hill is the perfect place to call home!

Newest College Hill Homes for Sale

$1,175,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2.1 Baths ⋅ 4051955 MLS

Set on a quiet, tree-lined street in Maplewood's enviable College Hill neighborhood, this house has the easy warmth and enduring character of a place made for settling in. Thoughtfully updated, while retaining its original character, this 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath home feels gracious without being too formal and polished without losing its charm. Gleaming hardwood floors, abundant natural light and period details make it especially inviting. The first floor flows from a spacious living room with a stone gas fireplace to a peaceful sunroom, inviting dining room, and refreshed kitchen with open sightlines and cheerful breakfast-bar seating. Upstairs are three comfortable bedrooms and a renovated hall bath with a double vanity. The private third-floor suite feels like a retreat, with a marble bath, radiant heat, walk-in closet and room to serve as a primary bedroom, guest suite or tucked-away office. The finished lower level adds flexible space for play, work or exercise, plus laundry and storage. Outside, the level, fully- fenced yard and stone patio create an ideal setting for playtime, pets, and relaxing evenings outdoors. A detached two-car garage provides storage, while thoughtful updates to the home's systems bring everyday comfort and peace of mind. Just 500 feet from the Maplewood Jitney, close to Maplecrest Park and the library, and less than a mile from Memorial Park, the Village, and the NJ Transit metro station, this is a house with heart, ready to feel like home.

10 Colgate Rd, Maplewood Twp.

$1,325,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4.1 Baths ⋅ 4051523 MLS

Fully renovated and impeccably finished, this stylish side-hall Colonial blends timeless character with sophisticated modern living. Set on a tree-lined street in College Hill, this 1925 residence offers sun-filled rooms, an inviting floor plan and exceptional indoor-outdoor living. A gracious foyer opens to the fireside living room and elegant dining room, showcasing original millwork and refinished hardwood floors. The chef's kitchen features quartz countertops, premium appliances, a beverage station, and access to the backyard and powder room. A versatile den with French doors opens to a private office. The second floor offers three generously sized bedrooms, including one with an en-suite bath and another with a private balcony, plus a hall bath and laundry room. The entire third floor is devoted to the primary suite, featuring a vaulted ceiling, abundant closet space and a spa-like bath with soaking tub, oversized shower and double vanity. The finished lower level expands the living space with a recreation room, wet bar and full bath. Outside, the private backyard retreat features a tiered patio and in-ground pool, creating a resort-inspired setting for alfresco dining, entertaining and relaxation. Extensive updates include new windows, lighting, HVAC systems and appliances. Ideally located near restaurants, parks, and NYC transportation, this exceptional home offers a rare combination of tranquility, modern comfort and urban accessibility.

28 Oberlin St, Maplewood Twp.

$1,350,000

5 Beds ⋅ 3.1 Baths ⋅ 4040959 MLS

Experience the perfect blend of modern luxury and architectural details in this fully renovated 2880 SF Colonial,ideally situated in the popular College Hill section. Finished across four spacious levels and refreshed inside and out--there is room for everyone here! Step inside and be captivated by gorgeous curved Maple moldings and trim, stained glass windows, built-ins, high ceilings, and a cozy gas fireplace in the living room. This smart home features a new 2-zone high-efficiency HVAC system managed by two new Nest thermostats for year round comfort. Gleaming refinished floors flow through the freshly painted interior, illuminated by new designer light fixtures and complemented by new solid-core interior doors. The new gourmet kitchen is a chef's dream, boasting custom quartz countertops and backsplash, premium Bosch and LG SS appliances, a built-in wine fridge, breakfast nook, and a classic Butler's pantry. Relax in the 3.5 completely new baths showcasing stylish designer tile, heated floors and premium fixtures. The Lower level boasts a Rec Room and a bonus room with an ensuite bath. The exterior boasts unmatched curb appeal with a new roof, new premium siding, freshly painted exterior trim, and new Pella windows. Enjoy the outdoors on the new Trex deck overlooking the backyard and appreciate the curb appeal of a newly paved driveway, smart myQ garage doors, new metal railings, a new sidewalk, and new elegant exterior lights. A rare, flawlessly updated turnkey gem!

22 Rutgers St, Maplewood Twp.

Start Your Search

The data displayed relating to real estate for sale comes in part from the IDX Program of Garden State Multiple Listing Service, L.L.C. Real estate listings held by other brokerage firms are marked as IDX Listing.
The information being provided is for the consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Copyright 2026 Garden State Multiple Listing Service, L.L.C. All rights reserved.

Updated: